| 1896 – 1897 | Frank A. Fielder |
| 1897 – 1898 | Frank Woodfield |
| 1898 – 1899 | J. E. Simpson |
| March 1900 – March 1901 | G.C. Reynolds |
| April 1901 – Sept 1901 | S. N. Clark |
| Sept 1901 – March 1902 | F. F. Voorhees |
| 1902 – 1906 | I. S. Whitaker |
| 1906 – March 1908 | W. H. J. Cattell |
| March 1908 – 1909 | B. J. K. Way |
| March 1909 – Nov 1909 | C. H. Dilks |
| Nov 1909 – May 1911 | George H. Van Note |
| May 1911 – April 1912 | J. A. Struyk |
| April 1912 – April 1913 | Vincent H. Van Horn |
| April 1913 – March 1914 | C. M. Holgate |
| March 1914 – March 1916 | Frank Woodfield |
| March 1916 – Aug 1918 | O. H. Bloomster |
| Aug 1918 – Nov 1919 | Ellinghouse |
| Nov 1919 – March 1920 | Robert M. Henry |
| March 1920 – March 1921 | Wilbert Gray |
| March 1921 – March 1922 | Charles E. Davis |
| April 1922 – March 1924 | Otis F. Van Brunt |
| March 1924 – Sept 1946 | Robert S. Childs |
| Sept 1946 – Sept 1953 | Frederick L. Hall |
| Sept 1953 – Oct 1955 | Rainold B. Rierson |
| Oct 1955 – Dec 1955 | Samuel Rumford (Died while Pastor) |
| Dec 1955 – Sept 1956 | R. D. Robinson (Robert) |
| Sept 1956 – Sept 1960 | Frederick H. Pagels |
| Sept 1960 – May 1962 | Robert Carlyon |
| June 1962 – Sept 1963 | C. Ronald Miller |
| Sept 1963 – June 1965 | William Henry Poe |
| June 1965 – June 1972 | H. Ellsworth Holmes |
| June 1972 – May 1977 | Horace Frantz |
| June 1972 – May 1973 (assistant) | Robert Bayley |
| June 1973 – June 1975 (assistant) | Theodore Gill |
| June 1975 – May 1977 (assistant) | Peter Starr |
| June 1977 – June 1985 | David Wilson |
| June 1977 – May 1979 (assistant) | Dennis Dewey |
| June 1979 – July 1979 (interim) | Larry Potts |
| Sept 1979 – May 1981 | Steve Tuell |
| June 1981 – Oct 1982 | Jeffery Taylor |
| Oct 1982 – May 1983 | Jeffery Taylor & Sally Bolitho |
| June 1983 – Dec 1989 | Bernard Duigon |
| Jan 1990 – April 1990 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| May 1990 – June 1990 (interim) | Newton W. Griener |
| July 1990 – Nov 1992 | Samuel Savage |
| Nov 1992 – Jan 1993 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| Jan 1993 – June 1993 | Nancy Fromm |
| July 1993 – June 1994 | Frederick Freese Jr. |
| July 1994 – Aug 1994 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| Sep 1994 – 1998 | Neill Tolboom |
| 1998 – 2000 | Joanne Wheaton |
| 2000 – 2002 | Milton Beeman |
| 2002 – 2004 | Lynn E. Wilson |
| 2004 – June 2015 | Elizabeth (Betty) Gibbons |
| July 2015 – June 2017 | Ernie Williams |
| July 2017 – June 2018 | Lawrence “Wren” Hillis |
| July 2018 – June 2022 | Denise Tiedemann |
| July 2022 – | Scott Clifton |
Serving Our Community • Connected To The World
Building on the Solid Rock of ChristJoin us as we Worship | Grow | Serve
Our Mission is to make disciples for Jesus Christ by proclaiming Him as Lord and Savior, and with the help of the Holy Spirit, be His representative in our community through worship, education and service.
MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Click below to make a difference. You share God’s love with others when you support the ministries of DeBows UMC using our secure online giving page. ~ Thank You