| 1896 – 1897 | Frank A. Fielder |
| 1897 – 1898 | Frank Woodfield |
| 1898 – 1899 | J. E. Simpson |
| March 1900 – March 1901 | G.C. Reynolds |
| April 1901 – Sept 1901 | S. N. Clark |
| Sept 1901 – March 1902 | F. F. Voorhees |
| 1902 – 1906 | I. S. Whitaker |
| 1906 – March 1908 | W. H. J. Cattell |
| March 1908 – 1909 | B. J. K. Way |
| March 1909 – Nov 1909 | C. H. Dilks |
| Nov 1909 – May 1911 | George H. Van Note |
| May 1911 – April 1912 | J. A. Struyk |
| April 1912 – April 1913 | Vincent H. Van Horn |
| April 1913 – March 1914 | C. M. Holgate |
| March 1914 – March 1916 | Frank Woodfield |
| March 1916 – Aug 1918 | O. H. Bloomster |
| Aug 1918 – Nov 1919 | Ellinghouse |
| Nov 1919 – March 1920 | Robert M. Henry |
| March 1920 – March 1921 | Wilbert Gray |
| March 1921 – March 1922 | Charles E. Davis |
| April 1922 – March 1924 | Otis F. Van Brunt |
| March 1924 – Sept 1946 | Robert S. Childs |
| Sept 1946 – Sept 1953 | Frederick L. Hall |
| Sept 1953 – Oct 1955 | Rainold B. Rierson |
| Oct 1955 – Dec 1955 | Samuel Rumford (Died while Pastor) |
| Dec 1955 – Sept 1956 | R. D. Robinson (Robert) |
| Sept 1956 – Sept 1960 | Frederick H. Pagels |
| Sept 1960 – May 1962 | Robert Carlyon |
| June 1962 – Sept 1963 | C. Ronald Miller |
| Sept 1963 – June 1965 | William Henry Poe |
| June 1965 – June 1972 | H. Ellsworth Holmes |
| June 1972 – May 1977 | Horace Frantz |
| June 1972 – May 1973 (assistant) | Robert Bayley |
| June 1973 – June 1975 (assistant) | Theodore Gill |
| June 1975 – May 1977 (assistant) | Peter Starr |
| June 1977 – June 1985 | David Wilson |
| June 1977 – May 1979 (assistant) | Dennis Dewey |
| June 1979 – July 1979 (interim) | Larry Potts |
| Sept 1979 – May 1981 | Steve Tuell |
| June 1981 – Oct 1982 | Jeffery Taylor |
| Oct 1982 – May 1983 | Jeffery Taylor & Sally Bolitho |
| June 1983 – Dec 1989 | Bernard Duigon |
| Jan 1990 – April 1990 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| May 1990 – June 1990 (interim) | Newton W. Griener |
| July 1990 – Nov 1992 | Samuel Savage |
| Nov 1992 – Jan 1993 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| Jan 1993 – June 1993 | Nancy Fromm |
| July 1993 – June 1994 | Frederick Freese Jr. |
| July 1994 – Aug 1994 (interim) | Horace Frantz |
| Sep 1994 – 1998 | Neill Tolboom |
| 1998 – 2000 | Joanne Wheaton |
| 2000 – 2002 | Milton Beeman |
| 2002 – 2004 | Lynn E. Wilson |
| 2004 – June 2015 | Elizabeth (Betty) Gibbons |
| July 2015 – June 2017 | Ernie Williams |
| July 2017 – June 2018 | Lawrence “Wren” Hillis |
| July 2018 – June 2022 | Denise Tiedemann |
| July 2022 – | Scott Clifton |
MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Click below to make a difference. You share God’s love with others when you support the ministries of DeBows UMC using our secure online giving page. ~ Thank You